This Week in BlogTalkRadio, 11/30-12/6

With Thanksgiving behind us and Christmas and Hanukah up ahead, it’s been a lively week ...

Partying with Cosby on BlogTalkRadio

Have you heard about Bill Cosby’s LISTENing parties? The New York Times just reviewed ...

Celebrating ‘The Twilight Saga: New Moon’

In honor of the opening day of New Moon, the latest film in The Twilight Saga, we thought we ...

 

Profile

MetroSistah

http://bwwe.org/


Country: United States

Language: English

Archived Blog Posts

Friends

  • Marcia McNair
  • GenXTalksUrNews
  • sankofasdaughters
  • Muhammads talk radio
  • DryerBuzz & Company
  • Doughboi
  • *Nikki*
  • Lisa Padilla

Comments

Fake Buddy

Fake Buddy

Welcome to BTR! ...........If ya get a chance, check out THE FAKE BUDDY SHOW!......... Also, please join us this Thursday at ...7 ...EST ....for a special special Valentine Show............. .Thanks, ..... .~Charlie~

MetroSistah  

Peace and Greetings--- "I haven't been around the world, but I've been around a few corners!" I look forward to going around a few more if it is God's Will. Besides my immediate family; my husband, children and grands, my greatest love and concern is for my Nation of People!

  • Archived Blog Posts

    Date / Time:

    NJNP: Beating Back Batson

    Beating Back Batson
    [col. writ. 9/6/08]  (c) '08 Mumia Abu-Jamal
     
     
        For those who read court opinions, few can ignore the U.S. Supreme Court's 1986 Batson v. Kentucky decision.
     
        Essentially, it prohibited the State from removing Black jurors for racial reasons.  It re-wrote the rules from the Swain v. Alabama ( 1965) case, where the court required systematic discrimination over a number of cases, over a period of years.  Needless to say, such a challenge was clearly beyond the resources of most people, and relatively few were made, and even fewer successful.  It is hard to resist the suspicion that this was merely judicial lip service to a principle that was easily ignored, in the breach.
     
        For, it took over a generation, over 20 years, for Swain to be overruled by Batson, and now, Batson is beginning to bear an eerie resemblance to its unworkable parentage, because courts have been loathe to grant relief, and have either created new rules, or simply ignored its dictates.
     
        We see this at work recently in a number of cases, among them Com. v. (Robert) Cook, WL 284060 (July 24, 2008).  In this case, the DA used 74% of his strikes to remove 14 Black jurors.  Incredibly, the Phila. Court of Common Pleas initially found that even this didn't constitute a prima facie case of discrimination. Later, it found a prima facie case, but ruled that the DA put forth sufficient race-neutral reasons for exclusion, and therefore not a violation of Batson.
     
        Recently, the PA Supreme Court agreed, even though the DA couldn't recall why he removed 2 Black jurors -- or, in other words, couldn't articulate a justification.
     
        Now remember -- Batson states that the improper removal of one juror violates the constitution.  One -- not 14.
     
        But here's the kicker.  The DA in Mr. Cook's case made a video training tape, where he taught his fellow prosecutors how to violateBatson - and how to lie about it to judges.
     
        but perhaps the then prosecutor, Jack McMahon, didn't need to work that hard, for courts would take up the slack.  For where the DA can't remember a reason, the court will invent one.
     
        This is especially egregious in this case, for the man who wrote the opinion was the DA when McMahon made the tapes, but now sits as Chief Justice of the court.  Can you spell 'conflict of interest?'  Did he recuse himself?  (What do you think?)
     
        For over a decade, Pennsylvania courts have painted McMahon as the bad guy, a kind of rogue prosecutor, and most of his convictions have been reversed (except Cook's), but McMahon wasn't, and never should've been, the issue.  For he was simply describing the pattern and practice of the office, and training his colleagues in techniques used over years of trials.
     
        Mr. McMahon was putting into words what DAs did to get convictions.  Does that mean his office sought a fair and impartial jury? In McMahon's words, " Well, that's ridiculous. You're not trying to get that."  In fact, McMahon explained, their jobs were to get the most "unfair" jury possible.  And, in many cases, that meant getting as few Blacks to serve on the jury as possible.
     
        Batson is as empty as Swain was, for if they don't want to give it up, any reason will do.
     
        They proclaim ideals of fairness that bear no relationship to the real process happening daily in courtrooms all across America.
     
        That would be, to quote McMahon, "ridiculous."
     
    -- (c) '08 maj
    ===============

    The Power of Truth is Final -- Free Mumia! 

    Audio of most of Mumia's essays are at: http://www.prisonradio.org

    PLEASE CONTACT: 
    International Concerned Family & Friends of MAJ 
    P.O. Box 19709 
    Philadelphia, PA 19143 
    Phone - 215-476-8812/ Fax - 215-476-6180 
    E-mail - icffmaj@aol.com 
    Web - www.freemumia.com
    AND OFFER YOUR SERVICES! 

    Send our brotha some LOVE and LIGHT at: 
    Mumia Abu-Jamal 
    AM 8335 
    SCI-Greene 
    175 Progress Drive 
    Waynesburg, PA 15370 

    WE WHO BELIEVE IN FREEDOM CAN *NOT* REST!! 

    Subscribe: mumiacolumns-subscribe@topica.com 
    Read: http://topica.com/lists/mumiacolumns/read 
    Subscribe ICFFMAJ email updates list by e-mailing 
    icffmaj@aol.com! 

    [Check out Mumia's latest: *WE WANT FREEDOM: 
    A Life in the Black Panther Party*, from South 
    End Press (http://www.southendpress.org); Ph. 
    #1-800-533-8478.]



        



    No Comments

Everything Else

Listen

 

 Participate

 

 Services and Terms

 

 Corporate

 

 BlogTalkRadio

 
BlogTalkRadio is a provider of thousands of internet talk radio shows. Our streaming and archived shows are produced by anyone that wants to be an internet radio host.
Give it a listen  and  
© 2009 BlogTalkRadio.com. All Rights Reserved.