DrFrankMurphy

A conversation with Nortin M. Hadler, M.D.

Author of Stabbed in the Back: Confronting Back Pain in an Overtreated Society Published November 15, 2009 $25.00 hardcover, ISBN 978-0-8078-3348-3

Q: How big, in round numbers, is the backache industry?
A:
The question does not lend itself to “round numbers.” Everyone has backache occasionally, some 5% suffer persistently. Backache is one of the commonest reasons to seek medical care; the commonest reason to see an osteopath, chiropractor, physical therapist, or other provider; the most costly compensable injury; a common component of the disabling conditions for which the Social Security Administration provides pensions; and the “bread and butter” of spine surgery. In short, backache is an important part of the fabric of life and of society.

Q: Just what is “regional backache”?
A:
This is a term I coined decades ago to denote the backache suffered by working-age adults who are otherwise well and that occurs in the course of customary activities without neurological damage.

Q: Do we know what causes it?
A:
Every theory imaginable has been raised and tested. None has survived.

Q: Haven’t various backache treatments been subjected to scientific testing?
A:
Thousands of randomized controlled trials have been done testing many inferences as to causation and many assertions as to treatment. Very, very little has survived this testing.

Q: You say that the idea of backache as an injury is a relatively new concept. How did this come to be and who is served by this idea?
A:
A century ago, Workers’ Compensation Insurance came on the scene. The worker is insured for the consequences of any personal injury that arises out of and in the course of working. This is a scheme that provides all the medical/surgical care and compensates for lost wages. To this day, it is the closest the U.S. has to national health insurance, although each state and several other jurisdictions administer distinctive programs. Early on, the notion of “injury” was straightforward, the consequence of a violent, traumatic event.

Backache did not qualify until surgeons in the early 1930s developed the notion of a “ruptured disc.” If the worker has suffered a “rupture,” the judiciary found, then the backache is a compensable injury regardless of the activity that was first associated with the pain.

Q: What’s the link between Workers’ Compensation and the labeling of backache as an injury?
A:
The notion of a “ruptured disc” found footing in Workers’ Compensation, but rapidly became part of the common sense. People could have a backache and exclaim “I injured my back.” Furthermore, the labeling as a ruptured disc ushered in the surgical era of disc surgery and the common sense that people have “bad backs” and suffer “wear and tear.”

Q: You mention that the prevalence of backache is much higher in Germany than in Great Britain. What accounts for the difference?
A:
I doubt the prevalence of the experience of backache differs. The recall of and the likelihood of reporting back pain differs and has increased remarkably in both countries in the past decades. No doubt this reflects the social construction of back pain as a dire injury, a symptom of being worn out.

Q: Tell me about “Railway Spine.” Does it have twenty-first-century equivalents?
A:
Whenever something new is introduced into our world, some new technology or new disease or the like, there is a period of discomfort. For some, the discomfort is easy to overcome, but not for all. The railroad was the engine of the Industrial Revolution, but it was a fright to behold. In Victorian Britain a new disease was described; people suffered pain in their backs and elsewhere, severe fatigue, mental fogginess, and fearfulness. The sufferers were all passengers who ascribed their severe, debilitating illness to the jostling and shaking experienced in passenger cars as trains moved. Queen Victoria herself would not allow her private train to travel at more than a snail’s pace. Her surgeon, Professor Erichsen, came up with theories about how the spinal cord had suffered a concussion. Law suits against the railroad companies for “Railway Spine” became commonplace. All this settled down in the early twentieth century as it became clear, even to Erichsen, that this was a psychosomatic illness, a form of mass hysteria.

There have been many examples since, such as the epidemic of carpal tunnel syndrome ascribed to keyboard usage (there is no hazard; nearly all who were labeled and operated on were mistreated.) The most dramatic examples are episodes of “sick building syndrome” when the rumor of some lurking hazard, some fume or toxin, makes all who are convinced feel ill. In Stabbed in the Back, I discuss “whiplash” and “fibromyalgia” as examples of potentially devastating illnesses that result from a noxious idea.

Q: When should someone suffering from regional backache seek medical attention?

A: When a person is concerned that the backache is not regional, that is, that there is a neurological symptom or the possibility of a more dire illness (metastatic cancer, etc). Or when the the need to cope with the backache and the need to cope with coincident challenges in life at home or work are competing to render the person more ill. Then a wise ear might be useful in helping the person sort this out.

Q: Are there any treatments that backache sufferers should be particularly wary of?
A:
The specific treatments for regional backache are called “modalities.” Some are physical (manipulation, massage, acupuncture, etc), some pharmacological (all sorts of pills, poultices, and potions), and some surgical. Almost without exception, no modality is helpful. In choosing to seek care, the sufferer is engaging in a “treatment act” that teaches theories of pain and the language such theories support. The sufferer should be aware of this, be willing to learn their vocabulary.

Q: Should we simply consider backaches a part of life that we need to cope with?
A:
Yes, but we should take to heart the lessons of the past century that the saga of regional back pain imparts. The symptoms are not trivial. Furthermore, the normal course of life offers up other challenges to our well being: heartache, sadness, heartburn, knee pain, and more. These, too, are not trivial. Furthermore, they are rendered even more disconcerting when they occur when other aspects of our life—our psychosocial milieu— are not in order. It is important to recognize the latter forest and not focus on the back pain or we will surely be engulfed in “treatment acts” to the detriment of our ability to cope with the confounding milieu—the psychosocial challenges of life at work and at home. If we can’t sort this out ourselves, we need helpful people trained to recognize these challenges.

Q: What would you say to a friend whose physician has recommended some sort of disc/spine surgery to “cure” his or her chronic regional back pain?
A:
There is a wealth of scientific information that there is no benefit to be derived from any form of surgery for acute or chronic regional back pain. There is also a wealth of information that patients subjected to invasive procedures for chronic regional back pain do even more poorly.

Q: In what ways is Stabbed in the Back critical of orthopedics and the chiropractic?
A: Stabbed in the Back
surveys the extraordinarily comprehensive science that informs therapeutic options for acute and chronic regional back pain. Neither orthopedics nor the chiropractic have “modalities,” that is, particular procedures, that can be shown to be helpful.

Q: Regarding back pain or injury, can you name some things that modern medicine does “right”—i.e., offers the consumer-patient a reasonable benefit-to-risk ratio?

A: In terms of evidence based alternatives, all that remains for the treatment of acute regional back pain is some acetaminophen and perhaps a single long-lever arm spinal manipulation if one is hurting for more than two weeks. For chronic regional back pain, there is no evidence based intervention to offer. However, there is a wealth of information that dissects the experience of these illnesses that could arm people with the insights and maybe the ability to cope until the natural history plays out in their favor.

Q: How would you describe the role that the insurance industry plays in the overmedicalization of American consumers? A: The American insurance industry is swimming in moral hazard. All Workers’ Compensation and nearly all health insurance provided by larger employers are contracted to “cost-plus providers.” The more people claiming and the more people who do not get well, the more cash flows through the coffers of the insurers from which a sizeable profit is taken. It is a system that is inherently conflictual.

Q: What would be the first thing that you would change about the American health- care system if given the chance?
A:
We have an enormous international resource that has spent nearly two decades cataloguing interventions according to the degree of effectiveness. No rational reform is possible until effectiveness becomes the primary criteria for indemnification. If “it” doesn’t work, I don’t care how well, efficiently, or cheaply “it” is done, I don’t want “it,” and I don’t want to share the cost of your getting “it.”

Q: Both Worried Sick and Stabbed in the Back propose that the modern American medical industry is essentially, perhaps even hopelessly, flawed by a system that puts too much stock in procedures and drugs that do not actually benefit the patient in any significant way. Do you see a trend toward reform among the younger generation of physicians? Have any medical schools adopted your theories and begun to teach their students about the dangers of overmedicalization and advocate for evidence-based medicine?

A: Every medical school teaches the principals of evidence-based medicine. Some governments have attempted to institute reforms along the lines I am advocating. However, the push-back by the stakeholders is relentless. The only solution is to teach the people to ask “Does this really do anything important for me?” and then demand a substantive response. Once the people realize how they have been scammed, reform becomes possible. Until then, the people will confuse the rational with rationing.


This interview may be reprinted in its entirety with the following credit: A conversation with Nortin M. Hadler, M.D., author of Stabbed in the Back: Confronting Back Pain in an Overtreated Society (University of North Carolina Press, Fall 2009). The text of this interview is available at www.ibiblio.org/uncp/media/hadler/.


PUBLISHING DETAILS ISBN 978-0-8078-3348-3, $26.00 hardcover Publication date: November 15, 2009 224 pp., 5 illus., 4 figs., 12 tables, notes, index http://uncpress.unc.edu/books/T-9058.html The University of North Carolina Press, www.uncpress.unc.edu 116 South Boundary Street, Chapel Hill, NC 27514-3808 919-966-3561 (office) 1-800-848-6224 (orders) 919-966-3829 (fax)

CONTACTS Publicity: Gina Mahalek, 919-962-0581; gina_mahalek@unc.edu Sales: Michael Donatelli, 919-962-0475; michael_donatelli@unc.edu Rights: Vicky Wells, 919-962-0369; vicky_wells@unc.edu

  1. Today's Best
  2. Top Shows
  3. Best of BTR
    1. Loading

      The Do's and Dont's of Fantasy Trade

      Oh that lost art of the fantasy sports trade.. In this week show your Hero Dennis Farrell and his guest Ed Pevos work out the do's and don't of the fantasy trade. With tips,tricks and the tools to help and protect yourself vs any trade sharks in the water who smell blood.

    2. I Love Me, I Love Me Not

      In the season of love we find ourselves focused on what other people think - about us, our relationship status, our place in life, and many other things that don't truly matter. But, what about that all-important love that all too often get’s missed - self love?

    3. Tribute to golf legend Billy Casper

      Ann's classic interview, a tribute to golf legend the late Billy Casper who talks about his most important wins, why he feels he wasn't recognized on the same level as Arnie, Jack and Gary Player, despite his incredible record and lots of fascinating stories.

    4. Powerlifting and Positivity

      Donnie "Super D" Thompson knows a thing or two about lifting heavy weights. He earned himself the nickname "Mr. 3000" by being the first human to total 3000lbs in powerlifting back in 2011.

    5. Gleneagles Falconry Instructor

      Steve Burdett, Falconry Instructor at The Gleneagles Hotel, talks about the history of falconry. He explains the different types of birds used in falconry and how they each have different purposes.

    6. Value of Human Interaction

      Derek wants to talk with you about the value of human interaction.

    7. Matt Sitkoff from NHL.com

      NHL On the Ice welcome Matt Sitkoff from NHL.com to talk fantasy hockey and the NHL season with us.

    8. Kristin Naragon, Director at Adobe

      Two-thirds of marketing directors say they are unhappy with their current email solution providers. Kristin Naragon with Adobe says the time is ripe for change.

    9. Defensive Back Keith Lewis

      This episode features discussions surrounding the New York Jets options in free agency and the NFL draft. Also an exclusive interview with defensive back Keith Lewis.

    10. The Demise of the American Mafia

      Interviewed George Anastasia, Author, "Gotti's Rules The Story of John Alite, Junior Gotti, and the Demise of the American Mafia"

    11. Newsweek's Matthew Cooper

      From LBJ to Hillary Rodham Clinton, politics is this week's subject on The Halli Casser-Jayne Show with LBJ's top advisor Joseph Califano, Jr. and Newsweek's political editor Matthew Cooper.

    12. Sacred Success

      Barbara Stanny hits it out of the park with her 8th book, Sacred Success.She speaks to where we're at in women once and for all not assuming men in our lives are more savvy, educated or equipped to create financial safety and freedom.

    13. The IQ of ADHD

      Host Jeff Copper interviews Dr. Thomas E. Brown on the impact of ADHD on intelligence and whether those with ADHD can have a high IQ. Dr. Brown was inducted into the CHADD Hall of Fame and received an Award of Honor from ADDA for his excellent work in ADHD.

    14. Critical Impact of Hiring Management

      How important is the recruiter or hiring manage when it comes to the hiring process and experience of a job seeker? Rayanne will chat with a seasoned hiring professional about the critical impact.

    15. SNL Writer Sylvia Traymore Morrison

      On the heels of Saturday Night Live's 40th Anniversary, "Somewhere in Vegas" throwback to an interview with SNL's first female African American writer Sylvia Traymore Morrsion.

    16. NHL On the Ice

      NHL On the Ice welcomes Dave Fischer, Senior Director of USA Hockey, to talk about Hockey weekend across America and the 1980 U.S. Olympic Ice Hockey on the 35th Anniversary of their historic win over the Soviet Union.

    1. Loading

      Small Business Unstuck

      Host Barry Moltz gets small businesses unstuck. He has founded and run small businesses with a great deal of success and failure for more than 15 years. This is a business radio show where he shares all the craziness of small business. It’s that craziness that actually makes it exciting, interesting and totally unpredictable.

    2. America's Most Haunted

      Official Internet radio show of forthcoming epic paranormal investigation book by Eric Olsen and "Haunted Housewife" Theresa Argie.